
[Photo depicts optimal results. Your mileage may vary.]
If there is one thing I love more than almost more than life itself, it’s pie. And if there’s one thing I hate almost more than anything in life itself, it’s making pie crust.
Everyone has a variety of unique gifts. And I have more than my fair share of really awesome talents and skills. Making pie dough, sadly, is not one of them. In fact, if there is anyone who is essentially cursed in the arena of pie pastry, I am that person.
Some people can just sift together flour and a little salt, crumb a pile of butter or shortening into the mix, sprinkle on a mere misting of water and with a little boardwork – hey presto! They’ve got a smooth, satiny and almost sensually compliant dough that almost seems to leap into the pan with a eager flourish, like those anthropomorphic animals in meat commercials that are ecstatic at the the thought of being slaughtered and eaten.
Then there’s me.
Watching me attempt to make a pie crust is very much like watching one of those funny videos of a horny animal who really wants to get it on with another who isn’t have any of it.
I shape, I roll, I pinch, I pray. But every time I push my pin across the dough it scoots out of the way, folding up over here and squeezing out over there, or cracking apart like the Antarctic ice sheet, sending an entire quarter of the dough off in some random direction at an angle so oblique to the central mass that it should be part of the geometry SAT section. As I shape one area, another disintegrates by either falling apart or sticking to the pin on the backswing. Or, more likely, both. I’m the only person I know who can, when rolling out dough, create more destruction with every stroke than order.
I chill, I hydrate, I flour, I use parchment paper, I wield a French style rolling pin. But the dough comes out either too crumbly or too sticky to hold together. Or both, amazingly. It alternately sticks to the pin and refuses to stick to itself in such random and unpredictable ways that I swear some bored demon with a “Food Physics” remote is amusing himself by randomly pushing buttons.
I’ve use all the “sure-fire tips” like substituting booze for water and adding more fat. I’ve tried every recipe (including my mother’s oh-so-ironically titled “No Fail Pie Crust”, which indeed never fails to make me tear out my hair). I’ve even begged. But no matter what I do, the dough just keeps scooting away from me like a disinterested mate, cracking, sticking, breaking apart, crumbling, mashing up, curling, twisting and/or comically clinging to the pin just long enough to get dragged off the edge of table, where it spectacularly releases en mass and drops to the floor.
And that’s just the prep. Once I manage to shape it into something resembling a post-Deep-Impact Eurasia that’s big enough to (hopefully) do the job, I still have to get it from the table to the pan. Let’s just say the process more closely resembles botched back-alley skin grafting than anything culinary in nature, and leave it at that. Trust me, the less said about it, the better. By the time I get my Frankencrust into the pan and pasted back together into a semblance of a crust, I’m usually on the verge of tears and the kitchen looks like a pastry chef went postal in a bakery with a chainsaw. Which, all things considered, is a not-entirely-inaccurate depiction of what actually happened.
And don’t even get me started on blind baking. I have to handle the damn crust twice, giving it twice the opportunity to find new ways to fail spectaculary, from burning on the edges while refusing to cook in the middle to sticking to the weight materials to crumbling apart on contact with a potholder. Seriously, just don’t go there. It makes me twitch.
This year’s pumpkin pie recipe called for 2 Tbs of spiced rum. Hubby borrowed far more than was necessary from the upstairs neighbors, and yet the entire quantity of donated rum has completely disappeared. Read into that what you will.